When I was in India just a few months ago for July, I gained a new appreciation for Prashant, Mr. Iyengar's son.
Prashant demands that we ask ourselves deep questions that have no definite answer.
I left his classes with more questions and a sense of vast openness. A sense that nothing and everything were available to me simultaneously if I only allowed my mind, allowed my normal outlook, what I everyday think of as 'me', to fall away. As soon as I found myself saying"I do it this way", or "that's not how I do this", I was going down the wrong road of self- definition, further and further from the vast expanse of divinity and freedom.
For what are we but slaves to our own frustrations, irritations and spells of impatience? We hold fast to our whims for new boots, fur ponchos and constantly seek a sense of final satisfaction. We lie to ourselves to make ourselves feel like we are intelligent and justified in our daily nonsense, but really we feel no real sense of completion. Instead, there is more loss, more emptiness, and we start out anew, looking toward some other object of desire, be it material or emotional to keep our ego pleased.
One class in particular has continued to have the most impact on me.
Prashant was asking us if we were 'correcting our pose' or if we 'made a correction' to the pose. He asked us to find out if we were in a state of constant correcting or if we felt like a correction had been made. "Are you doing or are you done?'
The entire class moved along with these questions being thrown out at us over and over again. When do you feel "done', what is "done"?
"How do you define done?"
"How do you decide it is correct?"
What is a correct pose?
What does it mean to be doing a pose 'correctly'?
To a certain extent there exists a level of incorrectness. Certainly, if the shoulders roll forward in Tadasana, that's an incorrect action. Depending on the shoulders, depending on the physical vessel, there may be a sway toward correctness or incorrectness. Does the state depend more on effort? What if the effort is great, but mis-directed?
Is there an absolute correct and incorrect?
I tend to think it has to vary from person to person, body to body. What our ego and our mind tells us cannot always be reliable. Sometimes our body speaks Greek, while we, for whatever reason, translate it as Spanish. Then we meet a teacher who understands Greek, informs us of our ignorance, and we either accept or reject the notions.
"The absolutes of right and wrong can never be absolute, because they are alive. Truth is worth caring about because it gives meaning to our lives, but we must watch for the high moral ground and use non-violence as a tool for connectivity and appreciation instead of divisiveness or puritanical authority."
from Yoga for a World Out of Balance by Michael Stone
Prashant would conduct an entire class without giving one instruction about a leg, a muscle or the spine. We were never told to straighten anything or tuck the tailbone. He expects that you are already in a place in your practice where you are aware of the basic doings and undoings, as well as your own shortcomings. I found it refreshing to discover that years of physical practice have finally begun to manifest somewhere beyond the physical, muscular realm for me. I was able to maintain the basics of the pose and still explore the breath, the state of mind, the concept of correct and incorrect.
I've decided to stop looking for the correct pose. Perhaps the correct pose is simply just another object of desire, when attained, we give ourselves an imaginary trophy on our mental award shelf. Can I just practice, uninterrupted, devoted to improving, devoted to evolving, without the trophy? I hope so.
The undisciplined man is attached to the fruits of his action and is in bondage to the desire that causes them. But the disciplined man abandons the fruits of his actions and thereby attains abiding peace.
For the delights that arise from external objects are really wombs of misery. They have a beginning and an end, Arjuna. A wise man takes no pleasure in them.
from The Bhagavad Gita translated by George Thompson
We should not be treating asana like an external object of desire to be attained and displayed. Asana is our laboratory, where our fears, frustrations and weaknesses are laid out before us to re-formulate.